BaketlyThis question has no general answer, and the guides that give one are the reason so many micro bakeries are underpriced. What a loaf should cost depends on your flour, your oven, your hours and your town. What it should never be is a number copied from the stall next door without knowing your own floor.
So: find the floor, find the ceiling, then choose.
The floor: what the loaf costs you
Your floor is the full cost of making one loaf, with your own time in it. Here is the worked example used throughout this blog:
| What goes in | Cost |
|---|---|
| Strong white flour, 500 g | $0.61 |
| Starter, salt, water | $0.09 |
| Paper bag and label | $0.35 |
| Your time, 24 min at $12/hr | $4.80 |
| Floor | $5.85 |
Below $5.85 you are paying for the privilege of baking. Not metaphorically — the loaf consumes more than it returns, and the more you sell the worse it gets. Working out your own version of this number is an afternoon's work once, and it changes every pricing decision afterwards.
The ceiling: what your market bears
A standard farmers-market sourdough loaf is commonly quoted in the $8–$14 range in the US, with enriched and specialty loaves higher. That band is useful for orientation and useless for your decision, because you do not sell to the US — you sell to a few hundred people within a short drive.
The benchmark worth having is the three nearest bakeries selling a comparable loaf. Not a national average, not what a blog says artisan bread is worth: the actual shelf price of actual bread near you, which is also the number your customer has in their head when they look at your table.
What each price between them actually pays
With a floor of $5.85 and $1.05 of materials in 24 minutes of work, here is what each price in the band does:
| Price | Margin | Pays you per hour |
|---|---|---|
| $7.00 | 16% | $14.88 |
| $8.00 | 27% | $17.38 |
| $9.50 | 38% | $21.13 |
| $11.00 | 47% | $24.88 |
| $12.00 | 51% | $27.38 |
| $14.00 | 58% | $32.38 |
Two things fall out of that table. The first is that the jump from $7 to $9.50 costs the customer $2.50 and nearly doubles what the morning pays you. The second is that above about $11 the gains flatten in percentage terms — you are no longer fixing an underpriced loaf, you are making a positioning bet.
Choosing
Three questions, in order:
- Is my floor below the local band? If $5.85 sits under loaves selling at $9–12 nearby, you have room and the decision is about position. If your floor lands above the local ceiling, you have a cost problem, not a pricing one — usually batch size.
- What does my price say? The cheapest loaf on a market is making a claim whether you meant it or not. If your bread is better, price it like it is; being 20% under the shop down the road is a strategy, but it should be a chosen one.
- Does it clear my hourly rate? If the price you land on pays less per hour than you would accept from someone else for the same work, the loaf is not a product yet.
Floor, ceiling, then a chosen point between them: that is the floor-and-ceiling method, and the choosing is the only part of it that has to stay a judgement. A recipe costing app like Baketly gives you the floor from your own pantry with your hours counted, and the ceiling from what bakeries near you charge, so the judgement is the only sum left.
The short version
Calculate the floor exactly — it is the only number in this that is knowable. Learn the ceiling from the three bakeries nearest you. Then pick a point between them on purpose, and check it pays you an hourly rate you would accept. Most underpriced loaves are not underpriced because the baker chose badly. They are underpriced because nobody ever worked out the floor.
Read next
- Why the 4× rule underprices your sourdough
- How to cost a recipe properly, once
- Did the market day pay for itself?
Questions
What is the average price of a sourdough loaf at a farmers market?
A standard loaf is commonly quoted in the $8 to $14 range at US farmers markets, with specialty and enriched loaves above that. Treat it as a band to locate yourself within rather than a target — the useful benchmark is the three bakeries nearest you, not a national figure.
Is it bad to be the most expensive stall?
Not inherently. Being the most expensive without a reason the customer can see is the problem. Being the cheapest without knowing your floor is far more dangerous, because it is the only position that can lose money on every sale.
Should I lower my price if loaves are not selling?
Check it is a price problem first. Loaves that do not sell at a market where comparable loaves do are usually a visibility, position or presentation problem. Cutting price costs you margin on every future loaf, including the ones that would have sold anyway.
How do I raise prices on regulars?
Raise once, by enough to matter, and say what changed — flour and butter are public facts and customers buy them too. Repeated small apologetic rises are more noticeable than one clear one.
What about discounts for buying two?
Only if the second loaf costs you less to make or sell, which at a stall it slightly does. A discount that just moves the same margin around is a price cut you have not admitted to.
Know your floor before you pick a price
Baketly costs the loaf from your own pantry, counts your hours, and checks it against what bakeries near you charge.
Download on the App Store